We all know the importance of a good night's sleep, and the feel of our mattress plays a major role in that comfort. But what makes a mattress more comfortable - mattress protectors or mattress toppers?

In this article, we will discuss the differences between these two accessories by looking at their benefits and why you might consider using them. This guide will help you to decide which is the right mattress accessory for you.

What is a mattress topper?

You may have noticed that mattress toppers have become rather popular, but what exactly are they?

Mattress toppers are just that - they sit on top of your mattress. People opt for a mattress topper for many reasons. They provide an added layer of comfort and can do wonders to soften a hard mattress.

If you want to transform your aged, slightly-lumpy mattress into a five-star resort hotel bed, then a topper is the perfect solution.

Different types of mattress toppers

Memory foam mattress toppers

A memory foam mattress topper is the most popular choice because of the levels of comfort it offers. Memory foam moulds to the body, giving you support in all the right places and allowing for an amazing night's sleep. Memory foam mattress toppers are affordable alternatives to purchasing a brand-new memory foam mattress.

Hollowfibre mattress toppers

Hollowfibre mattress toppers are brilliant if you prefer a softer bed. This springy material adds an extra layer of cushioning that can provide you with restful nights' sleep. These types of toppers can also be hypoallergenic, meaning they are resistant to dust mites and help those who suffer from respiratory issues. 

You’ll find that hollowfibre toppers are simple to maintain and are much more affordable than other mattress toppers. The Slumberdown Climate Control topper is a great example of this type of mattress topper since they use durable materials and improve breathability. 

Waterproof mattress toppers

Waterproof toppers are ideal for young children as these toppers add a layer of comfort while protecting the mattress from moisture. As an added bonus, a waterproof topper will also prevent mould and bacteria from growing.

Wool mattress toppers

Soft wool toppers are the perfect addition to tired mattresses that have those pesky indentations from sleeping in the same spot every night. A wool topper is a great all-year-round option as they regulate your temperature; keeping you warm and cosy in winter but cool and comfortable in summer. Wool toppers are preferred by those with hard mattresses who want their bed to be extra snug.

Cooling mattress toppers

Cooling toppers not only regulate your temperature and keep you cool, but they also provide pressure relief and are great for those with back pain. These mattress toppers are a fantastic choice for those who overheat easily at night or live in warm and humid climates. 

What are the benefits of a mattress topper?

• Allows you to transform an old mattress into a luxury mattress without buying a new one
• Soft bed toppers are perfect for helping mitigate back or joint pain
• Extends the life of your mattress by reducing wear and tear
• Improves sleep quality
• A good option for student housing or rental properties where you cannot replace the existing mattress

Are there any disadvantages of a mattress topper?

• Doesn't offer a lot of protection to the mattress - unless opting for a waterproof topper
• Can get hot easily while sleeping - unless using a cooling mattress topper
• Requires regular cleaning if used without a protector

What is a mattress protector?

Mattress protectors are an extra cover for your mattress that helps protect against staining, allergens and any wear and tear. This additional layer can extend the life of your mattress and help keep the sleeper's allergies at bay.

Although mattress protectors come in various sizes and use different materials, most mattress protectors are thinner than mattress toppers. This is because their intended purpose is to protect your mattress rather than add an extra layer of comfort.

If you want more information, read our ultimate guide to mattress protectors on this amazing bedtime product.

Different types of mattress protectors

Waterproof mattress protectors

Waterproof protectors, such as Slumberdown's Waterproof Mattress Protector, prevent liquid from soaking into the mattress. You can easily wipe away any spills without harming your mattress in any way. 

Hygiene is an important aspect to consider when we go to bed, especially for younger children and the elderly. Investing in a waterproof mattress protector will help reduce the risk of mould and bacteria forming and keep your mattress nice and clean. 

Cooling mattress protectors

Just like a mattress topper, a protector can also be cooling. These are great for people who experience night sweats as they are intended to help those who overheat during the night. Cooling protectors help to regulate your body temperature and keep moisture away.

Anti-allergy mattress protectors

Anti-allergy mattress protectors have been treated with an added antibacterial layer that discourages the presence of mould and dust mites. These are great for those suffering from allergies. Slumberdown's Anti Allergy Mattress Protector is the perfect solution if you find your allergies acting up while you sleep.

What are the benefits of a mattress protector?

• Helps your mattress last as long as possible
• Easy to wash and clean should spills occur
• Protects you from allergens in the mattress, allowing for a comfortable night's sleep
• Waterproof mattress protectors are perfect for young kids, the elderly or pets who sleep on the bed
• Protects you from chemicals sometimes used in synthetic mattress construction

Are there any disadvantages of a mattress protector?

• Depending on the fabric, it can be a bit noisy while sleeping
• Does not always improve comfort levels - some protectors can be quite bulky and oddly shaped
• Reduces mattress breathability

So, do I need a mattress topper or protector?

Whether you need a protector or a topper comes down to your preferences and needs. If your mattress is old and starting to feel uncomfortable, you probably need a topper to re-introduce a bit of luxury to your bedroom. 

Choosing the right mattress topper is not always easy, so you should take some time to ask yourself exactly what you need it to do. Consider the different materials and thicknesses to find the right match.

If you suffer from allergies or frequently eat or drink food in bed, then a mattress protector is the better option.

Both protectors and toppers help your mattress last longer. If that is your main requirement, consider the benefits of each to determine which one holds the most value to you.

Mattress toppers and protectors can both be hypoallergenic and repel dust mites. So, either one can be a great choice for allergy sufferers. 

You also don't have to use toppers and protectors in isolation. In fact, many people use both in conjunction.

FAQs

Should I get a new mattress or a mattress topper?

New mattresses are expensive, so most people opt for the more affordable mattress topper. A topper is an ideal solution if your mattress is slightly uncomfortable or too hard.

You should consider getting a new mattress if it is older than 6 to 8 years, has a noticeable dip, or is damaged.

Can I use a mattress topper instead of a mattress protector?

Mattress toppers are optional to improve the comfort of your bed, whereas mattress protectors are essential to keep your mattress clean.

If you really want to avoid staining your mattress and only had to choose one, go for a protector over a topper. This is because a topper does not always offer the same protective functions.

Can you use a mattress topper and protector together?

Due to the difference between toppers and protectors, you can use both for the best night's sleep. Using the two products together is pretty straightforward. Lay the topper on your mattress, making sure the corners align and then place the protector over the topper. That way, the life of the topper will also be extended.

Next, simply add your sheets and make your bed as you normally would. If you opted for a thick topper, you may have to purchase larger sheets to fit over the protector, topper and mattress.

Improve the quality of your sleep with Sleepseeker

Both mattress protectors and toppers are great additions to your sleep setup. Whether you’re looking for comfort or protection, at Sleepseeker we have a range of mattress protectors, pillows and duvets that can grant you a peaceful night's sleep.